ADHD Overwhelm: Where to Start When Everything Feels Urgent

In short

When ADHD overwhelm hits, don't try to prioritise in your head. Get everything onto one list, park whatever isn't for this week on a Someday list, and pick one small task that has been nagging you. Overwhelm is usually a clarity problem: too many open loops competing at once, and nothing chosen.

By Jim EbbelaarPublished 10 min read

For a long time my default answer was yes. A friend came to me with a business idea, and I was in. I said yes because I wanted to help, because new things excite me, and because I was scared of missing out.

Then each yes joined the pile in my head, and the pile never got quieter. I'd sit down to work and everything shouted at the same volume. I could overthink endlessly, let it spiral, and end the day having done nothing that mattered.

If that's where you are right now, this page is the order I use when everything feels urgent: what to do in the first ten minutes, how to choose, and what to stop saying yes to.

What should I do first when I feel overwhelmed with ADHD?

When ADHD overwhelm hits, the first thing to do is get everything out of your head and onto one list, before you try to choose anything. Overwhelm is rarely too much work. It is too many unfinished things held in your head at once, with none of them chosen.

So don't start by prioritising. Start by emptying. Take a sheet of paper, or one list on your phone, and put down every task, idea, promise and worry that's taking up space. No order and no dates. Ten minutes is enough.

I keep what I call a Someday list: a bucket for everything in my head, so it's out of my mind and in a system, and I don't have to schedule any of it yet. I've used it for years. It frees up the RAM in your head.

Psychologists call this cognitive offloading: using a physical action, such as setting a reminder, to lower the demand on your mind (Risko and Gilbert, 2016). A list on paper stays put. A list in your head keeps talking.

Why does everything feel equally urgent with ADHD?

Everything feels equally urgent with ADHD because nothing has been chosen, so every unfinished task keeps asking for your attention at the same volume. I call this the clarity problem: the ADHD brain sees too many possibilities at once, and without a choice they all compete.

I call each unfinished thing an open loop: the email, the form, the call you've been putting off for weeks. One open loop is small. Thirty of them, all held in your head, are a constant drain.

Research points the same way. In a series of experiments, unfinished goals caused intrusive thoughts during an unrelated reading task and worse performance on another task, and letting people make a specific plan for the goal removed those effects (Masicampo and Baumeister, 2011). Those experiments weren't about ADHD, so read them as a general finding.

For ADHD there's a second layer. A review of 38 studies found that adults with ADHD did moderately worse on working memory tasks, on average, than adults without it (Alderson et al., 2013). Working memory is what holds a few things in mind while you use them. The US National Institute of Mental Health also lists "poor time management, planning, or organization" and "trouble focusing on a large task or multitasking" among the ways ADHD causes problems in adult daily life (NIMH).

So the freeze makes sense: you're trying to store the whole list, rank it and start on it, all in your head.

How do I prioritise when everything feels important?

To prioritise with ADHD when everything feels important, stop ranking the whole list. Choose one or two big rocks for this season of your life, park everything else, and pick today's tasks only from those rocks or from what is truly due.

I teach this as two acts of clarity. The first is selection: your big rocks, two at most. A big rock is a direction with many tasks under it, like getting your finances under control. One question helps you find yours: if you could only work on one or two things for the next six months, and everything else had to wait, what would they be?

The second act is subtraction. Energy can't be created, only redirected, so choosing a rock means naming what waits. My own two are my business and my health. Because of that I skip some events, and I go to bed on time when friends are still out. I'm at peace with it, because I chose it. Without that choice, every skipped thing would turn into guilt.

Then sort the list you emptied out of your head:

Ask of each item Where it goes
Is it truly due in the next day or two, with a real consequence? Today. Three things at most
Does it move one of my two big rocks? This week
Neither? The Someday list. Not abandoned, just not now
Did I say yes without really meaning it? Hand it back, say no, or cross it off

Which task should I do first when my to-do list overwhelms me?

When a to-do list overwhelms you, do one open loop first: a small task under 20 minutes that has been nagging you for weeks and doesn't depend on anyone else.

That's the rule I use in our challenge, and it's small on purpose. Closing one open loop gives you one finished thing, and a bit of quiet where that task used to nag.

If you're stuck between two options, ask one question: is this choice easy to undo? Most of the choices we agonise over are. If it's reversible, pick one and start, because you learn more from doing than from another hour of research. For me, overthinking was often a tidier way to avoid starting.

Then give your one thing a time today. In the experiments above, a specific plan was enough to quiet an unfinished goal. And if you've chosen the task and still can't begin, the block has moved from choosing to starting. I cover that in why you can't start tasks you know how to do.

How do I stop saying yes to everything?

To stop overcommitting with ADHD, make no your default: if a request or a new idea isn't a clear yes, count it as a no. Every yes adds another open loop to a head that is already full.

I learned this rule from the investor Naval Ravikant, and for me it has been life-changing. My old default was yes. Now the default is no, and a yes has to feel obvious, in my gut or in plain logic. If there's real doubt, the doubt is the answer.

It feels uncomfortable at first. But a no costs you a moment of discomfort, and a commitment you never wanted costs you weeks of tension.

New ideas go the same way: onto the Someday list, where they're safe and out of your week.

What changes about overwhelm after 50 or 60?

After 50 or 60, ADHD overwhelm often changes shape, because fewer priorities are set for you. A job, a school run or a boss used to decide what came first. When those fall away, every task becomes optional, and optional tasks all feel the same size.

What I see with people in this stage of life is a list that has been growing for years: paperwork, the house, appointments, things promised to family. None of it has a deadline, so none of it gets picked, and all of it weighs.

The steps on this page are the same at any age, but nobody hands you the big rocks any more, so choosing them is the first job. If the house is the loudest thing on your list, it has its own guide: where to start decluttering when the whole house feels overwhelming.

What do I do on a day when I'm already overwhelmed?

On a day when you're already overwhelmed with ADHD, do less deciding and follow a fixed order: calm your body, empty your head onto one list, park most of it, and close one small open loop. This is the order I use:

  1. Breathe first. In through the nose, hold, and slowly out through the mouth, three times. I choose worse when my body is in alarm.
  2. Empty your head. Put everything onto one list. No order and no dates yet.
  3. Park most of it. Whatever isn't for this week goes to the Someday list. It waits there, and you stop carrying it.
  4. Name your big rocks. One or two, for this season of your life. Today's tasks should serve a rock or be truly due.
  5. Pick one open loop. Under 20 minutes, with nothing to wait on anyone for. Take the one that has nagged you the longest.
  6. Make the first step tiny and give it a time. Write the steps as if for a ten-year-old, because your brain doesn't freeze on tasks, it freezes on unclear tasks. Then do only the first step.
  7. Make no the default for the rest of the day. Nothing new comes in until that loop is closed. New ideas go on the Someday list.

Quick answers

Why do I make to-do lists but never do the tasks on them?

A to-do list stores tasks, but it doesn't choose between them. When forty items sit on one list with nothing chosen, the list becomes one more thing shouting at you. Keep the long list as your Someday list and pull at most three things into today.

Why do I do easy tasks first and avoid the most important one?

Easy tasks are clear and safe, and the important one is usually big, vague or a little scary. In my experience that's a clarity block or an emotion block. Break the important task down until the next step is obvious, and make that step small enough that it doesn't scare you.

Should I plan tomorrow the night before if I have ADHD?

Yes, as long as the plan is tiny. Choose tomorrow's one thing and when you'll do it, and put it where you'll see it in the morning. In the experiments above, a specific plan took an unfinished goal off people's minds, so you may have less to carry through the evening.

How we work on this in ADHD Harmony

ADHD Harmony is free to join. Connect your Google Tasks and Calendar and they sit in one place inside Harmony, with a Someday list for everything that has no date yet. On the free plan you can ask Jim's AI Twin one question a day, and "I'm overwhelmed, help me pick one thing" is a good one. Paid members can also let Jim's AI Twin plan the day with them, break a task into small steps, and join body doubling sessions.

When should you talk to a professional?

If the overwhelm is there most days for weeks, or it comes with feeling hopeless, talk to your doctor or a therapist. If you're in crisis or thinking about harming yourself, contact your local emergency number or find a helpline at findahelpline.com.

One thing, then the next

You don't have to sort out your whole life today. Empty your head, park most of it, and close one small loop. That's how the pile gets quieter: one chosen thing at a time.

Sources

  1. ADHD in Adults: 4 Things to Know. National Institute of Mental Health, 2024
  2. Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and working memory in adults: a meta-analytic review. Neuropsychology, Alderson et al., 2013
  3. Consider it done! Plan making can eliminate the cognitive effects of unfulfilled goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Masicampo and Baumeister, 2011
  4. Cognitive offloading. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, Risko and Gilbert, 2016
Jim Ebbelaar

About the author

Jim Ebbelaar

Founder of ADHD Harmony

Jim Ebbelaar was diagnosed with ADHD at 24. He founded ADHD Harmony, a coaching platform and community of more than 19,000 adults with ADHD, and has coached hundreds of people to build a life that fits their brain. He is a coach with lived experience, not a doctor or therapist.

Free

Join ADHD Harmony

Your ADHD Snapshot, the community, a daily check-in and one question a day to Jim's AI Twin.

Join free

Free. No card. You're in within two minutes.